Week 7
Part 1.
When
I engaged into this conversation I didn't think it would be hard or maybe it
was the partner I chose, but it was hard just to get a whole conversation in
without speaking or writing. All that came to mind was that I felt bad for
those people that can’t speak or write it must have been frustrating just
trying to make the other person to understand. Doing this assignment opened up
my eyes and made me have more patience. What I got from my partner was they
just wanted to give up because either I wasn't getting it or vice versa. I
could honestly say it was a difficult assignment because no matter how we moved
our hands, or air drawing or face movements we couldn't get the full conversation we expected. There was times when words would come out but we
would start again and I can tell by her fast movements of her hands she was
practically yelling at me without words.
My
goal was for me to be the leader in this conversation since it was my
assignment but that didn't go as planned. My partner was mainly in charge
because she wanted me to understand what she was trying to say and before
starting we chose a topic which was “What did we do today?”. I don’t think we
ever changed topics but we did go back and forth getting half of our
conversation. Even though there weren't any others included in our conversation
I still felt excluded she wanted to be the one sending me her message and for
me to understand. So I admit she had the power in this conversation.
I
think both have their positives sides to it because the ones that can speak
their whole population understand each other the same with those that can’t
speak. Overtime with many years you learn how to make each group (speaking and
non speaking) to understand what you’re trying to say until they find it
completely easy to communicate whether talking or not. I think both cultures
can benefit from each other and learn from one another which happen today.
Nowadays people who speak learn how to make others that can speak to understand
each other whether its hand and face movements. I think the attitudes that each
culture would be curious in wanting to learn how they can do that. I think it
would be nothing but positive attitudes from each culture.
Part 2.
The
second half of the assignment is much easier than part one even though I believe
body language is important in any conversation. I think what made the
conversation interesting was actually choosing a topic to talk about 15
minutes. The topic for the assignment was to talk about what we liked about
each other. (15 minutes were a breeze) My partner prefers body language as well
due to the fact that I wasn't showing any emotion and felt as if I was lying to
her. We both understood each other and got our conversation across to each
other without any difficulties.
I
think our language is very important with signs, like the saying goes “actions
speak louder than words” I think our hands or just body language would be our
actions which I think we can all agree to. You can tell so much about a person when
using body language you can tell how they are feeling whether its mad or happy.
I think people nowadays can communicate effectively with body language. I think
it has more meaning, power and trust but that’s just my opinion.
Everyone
should be able to read body language I think it’s very vital to our everyday
life. For example in an interview you want to sell yourself and you can be
hiding some potential talent and other have to see it and you want others to
see it. That would work best for the manager doing the interview. Maybe even
having a lot of friends who have different types or personalities, they could
be going to some tough times and they might not tell you but you can see it but
how they are acting.
Its very easy finding someone who doesn't understand body language. Especially when you’re in a group and you secretly
want to tell the person across from you something without having to yell but
they just don’t understand your body language. There is some benefits to not
reading someone’s body language like for one not getting into any trouble. For example
when taking a test and your friend trying to give you answers by using body
language, better to not understand and not keep looking up so you don’t get a
zero. Even then when your friend is giving you answers you probably cant make
out what answer he is giving you or for the same question that’s when it could
be unreliable.
Did you engage in a conversation in part 1 with you partner and both of you did not use spoken language? I think you were just supposed to use only signs and your partner was allowed to speak normally. No wonder you conversation was so difficult. It must have been very interesting though to have that experience of both just using signs and body language. I agree with you for part 2 that body language is key. My partner also thought that having a conversation was difficult and she said that it was very emotionless. I feel like that is why your partner said it felt as if you were lying to her. I did not think that not being able to tell someone's body language would be helpful but after reading your post it definitely changed my mind and made me think of other situations where it would be very helpful.
ReplyDeletethis whole entire time i did part 1 completely wrong haha! Great. No wonder but thanks for pointing that out but yeah it was very difficult. I was wondering how everyone else did but i see they did better than me.
DeleteIt's interesting that you found the second part (no body language or tonal inflection) easier than the first. I had a really hard time turning that part of communication off. Everything just seemed so fake without the physical cues lending authenticity to the words.
ReplyDeleteI like that you did the first experiment with BOTH you and your partner not using any words. I think that choosing a topic beforehand probably made that more difficult though. Letting a conversation develop more naturally might have made it so that you would have had an easier time communicating.
As mentioned above, you might have gotten different results if your partner had used her ability to speak fully. How did she retain power in the conversation without using symbolic language?
ReplyDelete" I think both cultures can benefit from each other and learn from one another which happen today."
That is a very positive and idealistic way of viewing this, but it doesn't answer the question and it doesn't address the reality of the situation. Which culture is better able to communicate complex ideas such as Einstein's theory of relativity or Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection? Could we even do science without spoken language?
Can you give a real life example of a speaking and non-speaking culture interacting?
For Part B:
"My partner prefers body language as well due to the fact that I wasn't showing any emotion and felt as if I was lying to her"
That is very telling and you could have done a lot with that. Non-spoken language contributes meaning and clarification, but it also allows people to verify what you are saying, kind of like a lie-detector. If your body language doesn't match the words you are saying, this tells the person that you aren't telling the truth and perhaps can't be trusted. Why would this be beneficial in an adaptive sense?
There is natural variation in all of our abilities to read body language, just as with any trait, but there are specific groups that have significant impairment in reading body language, such as those in the autism spectrum and also (to a certain degree) those who are blind.
While I see your point on your test example, you are just ignoring your friend entirely, not just his body language, to avoid getting into trouble! Can you think of a situation where you wouldn't understand the body language you were seeing and be at risk of misinterpreting it? Do all cultures use the same system of body language?